For Sale

916 Pohalski Street

KEY WEST, FL 33040
Browse all 30 photos


Very rare opportunity to own a piece of Key West History! The iconic Coffee Mill in Old Town, Key West is one of the most recognizable buildings on the island. Built prior to 1907, the property was home to an active coffee bean processing plant until the 1950's. In recent years, the building was famously home to one of Key West's most popular dance studios -- and now is being used as a holistic medicine and wellness center. The current owners have done extensive renovations to update the space to today's standards while maintaining many of the historical features of the property. Updates include a complete modernization of the electrical and plumbing systems, new central A/C and ductwork, masterful restoration of the original hardwood floors, and the construction of private treatment rooms and a business office -- all while preserving the original exterior and character of the building. Additional features include multiple skylights, a period correct metal shingle roof, beautiful historic arched transom windows salvaged from Henry Flagler's Casa Marina hotel, and an updated bathroom. The property is up to current building code and ADA compliant, and was awarded a Ceramic Star for historic preservation and a Certificate of Excellence by The Historic Florida Keys Foundation. The Coffee Mill has been a staple in Old Town for over 100 years and continues to be an important part of the historic district. Commemorating its roots, a section of the milling equipment has been preserved and is on display in the main room of the Mill. Located just steps from world famous Duval Street and walking or biking distance to the island's best restaurants, shopping, and galleries. If you're looking for a space that's as unique as Key West itself, look no further than the iconic Coffee Mill. Easy to show!One more thing needed is to update the writeup for Coffee Mill.**Zoning Verification Letter in hand.**Property is eligible to apply for a residential unit via BPAS.

  • Interior Details
    • Beds & Baths
      • Bathrooms:1.00
  • Construction Details
    • Type & Style
      • Property type:Purchase
    • Condition
      • Year built:1907
  • Community and Neighborhood Details
    • Community
      • Subdivision:Old Town - Unlisted (1.0)
  • Other
    • Source
      • MLS #:604849


Paul TejeraReal Estate Group
  • Request Info
  • Schedule Showing
By submitting your info, you consent to the Privacy Policy.

Interested in Purchasing 916 Pohalski Street?

Get an estimate on monthly payments on this property.

Note: The results shown are estimates only and do not necessarily include accurate taxes or homeowner's insurance!

Monthly Payment